By Dr Imitiaz Khan and Ali Shahaab
The digitalisation of public services saved the government more than 1,400 years of working time and allowed the nation to surpass the US in its struggle against election meddling, say observers.
People around the globe have been watching the build up to the US election with disbelief.
Particularly confusing to many is the furore over postal ballots, which the US president, Donald Trump is insisting will lead to large-scale voter fraud – despite a complete lack of evidence to back this.
And yet this issue has become a central feature of the debate.
Citizens of Estonia, a small nation in the Baltic region, will perhaps be particularly perplexed: Since 2005, Estonians have been able to vote online, from anywhere in the world.
Estonians log on with their digital ID card and vote as many times as they want during the pre-voting period, with each vote cancelling the last.
This unique technological solution has safeguarded Estonian voters against fraud, use of force and other manipulations of remote voting that many American voters are apprehensive about in the 2020 US election.
Voting online is just the start. Estonia offers the most comprehensive governmental online services in the world.
Leading the World as a Digital First Nation
In the US, it takes an average taxpayer with no business income eight hours to file a tax return. In Estonia, it takes just five minutes.
In the UK, billions of pounds have been spent on IT, yet the NHS still struggles to make patient data accessible across different health boards.
In Estonia, despite having multiple private health service providers, doctors can collate and visualise patient records whenever and wherever necessary, with consent from patients – a real boon in the country’s fight against coronavirus.
Branding itself the first “digital republic” in the world, Estonia has digitised 99 per cent of its public services.
And, in an era when trust in public services are declining across the globe, Estonia persistently achieves one of the highest ratings of trust in government in the EU.
The Estonian government claims that this digitisation of public services saves more than 1,400 years of working time and 2 per cent of its GDP annually.
People prepare to vote in the 2019 Estonian parliamentary election, when 43.8 per cent of all participants voted over the internet.
The foundation of this digital republic dates back to 1997, a time when only 1.7 per cent of the world population had internet access, a start-up called Google had just registered its domain name and British prime minister John Major was celebrating the launch of 10 Downing Street’s official website.
Meanwhile, the government of the newly formed state of Estonia envisaged the creation of a digital society, where all citizens would be technologically literate and governance would be paperless, decentralised, transparent, efficient and equitable.
Making the Internet a Human Right
The young post-Soviet government decided to ditch all communist-era legacy technologies and inefficient public service structure.
In a radical move, the government – which had an average age of 35 – also decided not to embrace western technologies.
Neighbouring Finland offered an analogue telephone exchange as a gift and the Estonian government declined, envisaging communicating over the internet rather than analogue telephone.
The government of Estonia launched a project called Tiigrihüpe (Tiger Leap) in 1997, investing heavily in development and the expansion of internet networks and computer literacy.
Within a year of its inception almost all (97 per cent) of Estonian schools had internet access and by 2000, Estonia was the first country to pass legislation declaring access to the internet a basic human right.
Free Wi-Fi hotspots started being built in 2001, and now cover almost all populated areas of the country.
The government also understood that, in order to create a knowledge based society, information needs to be shared efficiently while maintaining privacy.
This was a radical understanding, even in the context of today, when for most countries, data sharing among different organisations’ databases is still limited.
It is predicted that by 2022, 93 per cent of the world’s total data collected or stored will be such “dark” or siloed data.
Two decades ago, in 2001, Estonia created an anti-silo data management system called X-Road through which public and private organisations can share data securely while maintaining data privacy through cryptography.
Initially developed by Estonia, the project is now a joint collaboration between Estonia and Finland.
A large number of Estonian government and financial institutions using X-Road came under cyber-attack from Russian IP addresses in 2007.
This attack made clear how vulnerable centralised data management systems are, and so Estonia required a distributed technology that is resistant to cyber-attack.
Addressing this need, in 2012 Estonia became the first country to use blockchain technology for governance.
Deploying Blockchain Protection
Distributed ledger technology, commonly known as blockchain, is the underpinning technology of the cryptocurrency Bitcoin.
The technology has moved on significantly since its inception in 2009 and is now used for a variety of applications, from supply chains to fighting injustice.
Blockchain is an open-source distributed ledger or database system in which an updated copy of the records is available to all stakeholders at all times.
Due to this distributed nature, it is almost impossible for a single person or company to hack everybody’s ledger, ensuring security against cyberattacks.
Deploying blockchain technology not only ensures protection against any future attacks, but also poses many other benefits to Estonians.
For example, in most countries citizens have to fill in many different forms with the same personal information (name, address) when they need to access public services from different government agencies.
In Estonia, citizens only need to input their personal information once: The blockchain system enables the relevant data to be immediately accessible to the required department.
This might scare people worried about data privacy. But citizens, not the government, own their personal data in Estonia.
Citizens have a digital ID card and approve which part of their information can be reused by which public service.
Estonians know that even government officials can’t access their personal data beyond what is approved by them for the required public service.
Any unauthorised attempt to access personal data will be identified as invalid: Indeed, it is a criminal offence in Estonia for officials to gain unauthorised access to personal data.
This transfer of ownership and control of personal data to individuals is facilitated by blockchain technology.
This should be an inspiration for the rest of the world. It is true that most countries do not have similar circumstances to post-Soviet Estonia when the Tiger Leap was introduced.
But the same futuristic mindset is required to address the challenge of declining trust.
This commentary first appeared in The Conversation.
About the Authors
Dr Imitiaz Khan is a Reader (Associate Professor) in Data Science at Cardiff Metropolitan University and leads the Data Science and Artificial Intelligence Lab, where he is currently supervising blockchain focused PhD studentships investigating different approaches of utilising blockchain technology – to ensure the data integrity of 4.5m VAT registered companies in UK (with Companies House); to identify fraudulent activities in cryptocurrency transaction using artificial intelligence (with Coincover); to establish a blockchain and smart contract based marketplace for digital health records (with Balsamee). Imtiaz also founded the Hub for Distributed Technologies and Future Societies at CardiffMet – a multidisciplinary research hub incorporating academics from four different schools to investigate the adaptation and impact of distributed technologies like blockchain on future society.
Ali Shahaab is a PhD candidate at Cardiff Metropolitan University. His research focuses on the feasibility of Distributed Ledgers (DLTs) and Blockchain Technology to guarantee the integrity of Companies House UK data. Key areas of his research are DLTs frameworks, security, privacy and immutability aspects of DLTs and Blockchain as well as legislative and deployment challenges. He also has a passionate interest in utilising blockchain technology to solve real world issues around trust, transparency and identity. Having MSc in advanced computer science from University of St. Andrews, UK and BS in Computer Engineering from Comsats Islamabad, Pakistan, Ali has a strong grip on software systems, distributed computing, cryptography and information systems.
